Sunday, November 14, 2010

Ennui

I don't know what's gotten into me. Ennui.

I think it had something to do with arranging my classics books--double-stacking all the Latin on two shelves--and discovering innumerable forgotten books.  Joyce Carol Oates among the Cicero, a biography of Emily Dickinson among the elegiac poets, and a rousing historical novel about Cassandra with the Virgil.

So many good books to read.  But when?  

Conscious of this, and also of the fact that I will read most new books only once, like John Casey's well-written new novel, Compass Rose, I have cut back.

So I've declared a moratorium on books...but I really do want a new book.

At Borders:  nothing. I bicycled out there the other day.  I carried several books over to one of the comfortable chairs and dipped into Kate Morton's new novel and a biography of Cleopatra.

But I wasn't sure I would read them.  I wasn't in the mood.

I almost bought Susan Cheever's new biography of Louisa May Alcott.  But at the last minute I needed to avoid somebody:  you know, somebody very nice, but sometimes you're just not in the mood.  So I raced out the door, sans book, of course, and rode home. 

At B&N:  I thought about buying Tales of the City.  Good thing I didn't because I found my copy at home.  I want to reread the Tales of the City series so I can catch up before reading Maupin's latest novel about Mary Ann Singleton. Many of us in an office years ago passed these novels around and exchanged humorous observations about Mary Ann, Anna Madrigal, and Michael Tolliver.


Then I almost bought Susan Cheever's new biography of Louisa May Alcott but they didn't have it.  A clerk probably could have found it for me, but there was someone I wanted to avoid again.  I'm haunted these days by people I want to avoid.  

This is called Teaching and Running.

Amazon. I've put some books in my cart lately and not bought them. Do you think I should buy Susan Cheever's biography of Louisa May Alcott? Or pass.  Or maybe some science fiction; I've been craving science fiction lately.  Any suggestions?

Friday, November 12, 2010

The Influence of Latin on Margaret Drabble, Marilynne Robinson, Mark Zuckerberg, & Tom Holland

My favorite novel:  a Virgil class plays a starring role.
I'm rereading Margaret Drabble's The Seven Sisters, easily my favorite novel.  There are a few slight eerie similarities between the narrator Candida and myself.  Candida takes an evening adult class on Virgil, mostly in translation but with access to the Latin, and becomes fascinated by Aeneas' visit to the underworld (Aeneid, Book VI). She learned her Latin at a girls' school, where she had an excellent teacher,  and very much respects her elderly arty teacher at the Further Education college, Mrs. Jerrold.


I didn't learn my Latin at a girls' school.  I studied Latin at the university and I taught Virgil's Aeneid in Latin eight or nine times in my early career.  I also snuck it into an adult education class (in English).  I feel a strong affection for the unconventional Mrs. Jerrold, a teacher and a poet, with her dyed black hair, bandeaux, "red lipstick, green eyeshadow, and magenta earrings."


"She was a parrot, a macaw.  She was a sprightly old thing, and she knew her Virgil.  I wonder how she is now.  I wonder if she needed the money.  Those classes pay terribly, I know, but they do pay something."


Candida affirms herself and grows through her experiences reading Virgil.  A superannuated housewife, she leaves her husband, a headmaster who has an affair with the mother of a child who committed suicide at the school. He manages somehow to get everyone's sympathy, or so Candida thinks.  Candida exiles herself from Suffolk to a neighborhood in London that is neither quite going up or going down.  She has never worked, except as a substitute at her husband's school (which sounds like very hard work, by the way) and does not have a job now or feel that she has the capacity to take a job.  She writes her diary on the computer and sees herself as gray and aging, though she is only in her 50s, unnoticeable.  The Aeneid fascinates her as she feels on the edge of the underworld herself--"Book VI is an invitation," she says at one point.  She is also like Dido (Book IV, the other book that fascinates her), jilted by the leader Aeneas, her use over now that her "husband" has left the marriage.


"Nothing much happens to me now, nor ever will again.  But that should not prevent me from trying to write about it.  I cannot help but feel that there is something important about this nothingness.  It should represent a lack of hope, and yet I think that, somewhere, hope may yet be with me.  This nothingness is significant.  If I immerse myself in it, perhaps it will turn itself int o something else.  Into something terrible, into something transformed....I will have faith that something or someone is waiting for me on the far shore."


Candida is completely alone in her bleak flat in London.  She is not unhappy, though.  She plays solitaire on the computer.  In her early days in London, she looks forward to her weekly Virgil class as an anchor.  They do only a few lines a time, comparing translations and looking at the Latin closely.  I'd love to take this class.


"We were a nice class.  We were nice even to our own mad member, an old man called Mr. Wormald, who had a fixation on poor Mrs. Jerrold.  He tormented her.  We were all very tolerant with him....  He was a terrible man.  He was the only man in the class.  But we were kind to him, we made a space for him amongst us.  I can't imagine why he was interested in Virgil.  I don't think he was, really."



There is sometimes a "mad" member in these Latin classes.  I very much like some mad people, but there's something about ancient languages that attracts them--and then the classes turn out not to be like Dungeons and Dragons, as they'd hoped, and they want to digress all the time, or turn on the teacher, or secretly think they could teach the class themselves, but there's one problem:  they don't know the Latin. 


The majority of students are charming, though, and come from all walks of life to learn the Latin. 


After the Further Education College is turned into a health club, Candida eventually manages to reunite the Latin class.  She plans a group trip to Carthage and to Naples, following the route of Aeneas, and liberates herself. This is so exciting for me.  How I'd love to go on Candida's tour.  Latin is liberating.  Virgil is the key to so much...  As I always point out, T. S. Eliot says he's the best poet in any language.


And every time I read The Seven Sisters I see more in this novel, though I have written only a little here. There is more than Virgil, by the way.  But without Virgil, there'd be no novel.


More about this later.  For the moment, I want to point out that Everybody's Talking about Latin These Days.   

Marilynne Robinson recently gave a speech at Skidmore College  and discussed "the great influence that Latin has had on her writing. Robinson said that she considers Latin to be an important subject that is increasingly overlooked. 'If you want your prose to be good, studying Latin is good for you,' she said."

Mark Zuckerberg, founder of Facebook, has been recommending the Aeneid lately. Columnist Alex Beam commented in The Boston Globe:

"Of course you have noticed Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg’s uncontrollable tic — quoting from Virgil’s Aeneid.’ He did it twice during a long New Yorker interview and more recently in Wired magazine, where he popped — in Latin — what might be the epic’s most famous line: 'A joy it will be one day, perhaps, to remember even this’' (trans. Robert Fagles). Those are Aeneas’s consoling words to his battered, shipwrecked comrades. In the poem, various gods assure the Trojan hero that he will found 'an empire without bound,’' i.e. Rome, which is more or less what Zuckerberg has done. Facebook has more than 500 million active users and counting."

Tom Holland, author of Rubicon, Persian Fire, and Millennium, writes about the rise and fall of the  Roman Empire in  The Guardian.


And he mentions Virgil.  "Virgil, the great laureate of his people's achievement, saw in it the fulfilment of a mission entrusted to them by the gods. "Your task, O Roman," he wrote in celebrated lines, "is to rule and bring to men the arts of government, to impose upon them the arts of peace, to spare those who submit, to subdue the arrogant."

Thursday, November 11, 2010

Ron Charles: National Book Awards

Ron Charles of The Washington Post is hilarious in this video  about the National Book Awards.  Sorry, I can't figure out how to embed a video, but follow the link.

Tuesday, November 09, 2010

Compass Rose

John Casey's novel, Spartina, won the National Book Award in 1989. His new novel, Compass Rose, the sequel, can be read on its own, but of course it is helpful to have some background. I did not reread it, but I've done a little research for you: in Spartina, Casey explores class issues and the conflict between fishermen and developers in a town in Rhode Island.  The hero, Dick Pierce, a fisherman, builds a boat in an attempt to control his life and business. He also has an affair with upper-class Elsie Buttrick, who has his baby. Naturally, this causes anguish to his wife, May.

These details are quickly recounted at the beginning of the new novel, Compass Rose, but the perspective is entirely different.  Casey relegates Dick to the background and focuses on the relationships between the women:  Elsie, a natural resources officer for the state who spends most of her time thinking about sex even when she is patrolling the marshes; her daughter, Rose, who grows up to be a talented singer; Dick's wife, May, a rather shadowy character whose life with Dick has been shattered by Elsie, but who kindly becomes a second mother to Rose; and Mary Scanlon, a chef who lives with Elsie to help take care of Rose.  

This arresting, traditional novel is written very much in the style of the fiction of the '70s and '80s, before the passion for overstuffed historical novels swept  American writers and changed the show-don't-tell style of writing to what I call tell-and-show.  One can breathe deeply and enjoy the immediacy of a novel like Compass Rose, which refreshingly isn't crammed with historical information between the lines.  Set in the late 20th century, sometime before cell phones and computers fractured attention, the scenes of Casey's new novel are simply but luxuriantly developed, unfolding at a slow pace that reflects a more concentrated attention.  The quotidian details of the women's lives are beautifully revealed. 

But here is my problem. I love Casey's writing, but I don't believe in Elsie.  Casey is in love with Elsie, who seems very much a male fantasy to me, sportswoman-dominatrix by day, trollop by night (at least in her youth).  She has a "trailer-park trash" air, and I have to keep reminding myself that she is upper-class, has rich relatives, and owns the house she shares with Mary.  She is a self-centered woman who dislikes other women, whose idea of sexiness is to wear a red dress and have sex clandestinely in the bushes, who enjoys seducing men but does not want a relationship. Yet she wants to be at the center at all times.  She does not have friends. In one scene, while she is doing her ranger stuff, she spies on a fisherman breaking some rules and has a voyeuristic sexual fantasy. I wish this were sexy: I found it simply bad sex.  Elsie is not the kind of women women like: we prefer a little loyalty.  Poor May!  In fact, I know very few like Elsie--thank God!

But, as Casey reminds us, she is a bright woman who attended an exclusive school and studied Latin. (Latin stands for all good things, as it should.)  The Latin is mentioned again, again, and again, because Elsie was the favorite student of one of the most fascinating characters in the book, Miss Perry, a prim, eccentric, philosophical retired Latin teacher, who has a strong bond to Dick and his family.  

I am very impressed by Miss Perry's vision of death:  she has a dream in which death is the loss of grammar.  She very much does not want this.  A nightmare for Latin teachers.  Elsie takes care of Miss Perry after she has a stroke.  Elsie's love of Miss Perry is probably her most likable quality.  I wanted to see what Miss Perry saw in her.

So this is a mix of perfect sentences, marred for me by a post-feminist cartoonish heroine who I rather think some other women will have a difficult time accepting, too.  I am not yet finished, however, and if Elsie becomes real to me I'll let you know.

Saturday, November 06, 2010

Hereafter

Dickens' Dream
Matt Damon's performance in Hereafter, the brilliant Clint Eastwood movie that opened to mixed reviews last month, is understated but dazzling.  The 39-year-old actor, who was nominated for an Academy Award for his role in Invictus, does not allow himself to be seduced by the histrionic potential of Eastwood's exploration of the supernatural aspect of death.  Damon has a talent for conveying the unglamorous side of life.  He plays George as a quiet, ordinary man who is saddened and numbed by his psychic talent to communicate with the dead. George is unable to lead an ordinary life. He touches a woman's hands and is instantly in touch with her sorrow. Women freak out; the bereaved pursue George even after he gives up readings.

Instead, he reads Charles Dickens obsessively.  

Of course I was thrilled to have this bond with George.  What could be more charming than another fan of Dickens, even in a film? He listens to the audiobook of David Copperfield in his apartment in San Francisco and later has a chance to hear Derek Jacobi give a reading of David Copperfield at a book fair in London.  (By the way, there is no Derek Jacobi audiobook of David C.  Perhaps they should rethink that.  Certainly fans will want to buy it.)


Book fairs!  London!  Yes, of course you have to see this movie.

And there is a scene in the Dickens Museum.  Damon touches Dickens' desk and looks serenely thrilled when he sees Robert Buss's painting, "Dickens' Dream,"  a painting of Dickens surrounded by his characters.

There are other characters in this movie, but Damon is the center and the glue that holds it together.  

In real life does he like Dickens? 

Film critic James Rocchi, in an interview at the blog, the Rocchi Report, asked Damon if working on Hereafter made him a Dickens fan. 

“No, I always liked him. It was interesting, actually. Peter (Morgan) actually even wrote it in the script, and I talked to him about it. He says, ‘Most people would say Shakespeare, but Dickens for me is really the guy.’ We went and shot at the Dickens museum and (at) that picture, the Dickens dream picture. When you see it, it’s Dickens sitting at his desk and all of these characters in his books kind of bent around him; they’re in his imagination, but they’re like these ghosts that are haunting him, almost. So it’s like a perfect parallel for George, for the character who has these visions. And so it’s like in that moment George realizes maybe that’s the reason he’s always felt so connected to Dickens — because in fact he may have been having a similar type of experience on Earth.”

Fascinating movie--do see it for the stunning acting. It's like M. Night Shyamolon, only through the lens of Clint Eastwood.

Friday, November 05, 2010

Pasternak, Maupin, Morton, & More

BORIS PASTERNAK:  Ann Pasternak Slater, a writer, translator of Tolstoy, and the niece of Boris Pasternak, crucifies the new translation of Dr. Zhivago in her hard-assed review in The Guardian.  Since no one dares to question the superiority of award-winning translators Richard Pevear and Larissa Volkhonsky, her declaration that their new translation is clumsy and too literal is shocking.

Slater says:

"It's instructive to check Volokhonsky-Pevear's English against the Russian. Its painful ineptitudes can regularly be defended by a Russian source. Yet the original isn't inept. It's simply been badly translated. Pasternak's Russian is packed, concise, colloquial and muscular. Volokhonsky-Pevear's English is prosaic, flabby and verbose. It often renders Pasternak's more philosophical passages incomprehensible. It's far worse than the compact, natural and always lucid prose of Hayward and Harari."

I am enjoying this new translation but do find it dense in parts. Occasionally I skip back to the old Haward-Harari translation.

My main problem, however, is not with the translation but with the design of the Pantheon edition:  the 513-page book is enormous, there is too much print on the huge pages, and I would much prefer, though this sounds trivial, to see more readable print on, say, 1,000 pages.

TALES OF THE CITY:  Armistead Maupin's Mary Ann in Autumn:  a Tales of the City Novel is new on the bookshelves.  I love this series; maybe it's time to reread it.  In this review in The San Francisco Chronicle, the reviewer, however, has a few problems with the characters' age.


"The Castro in 2010 isn't nearly as much fun as Russian Hill in 1978, and Collingwood Street cannot compare with Macondray Lane. To make matters worse, Anna Madrigal in Armistead Maupin's new book, "Mary Ann in Autumn," is old - when we first meet her she is lying on the kitchen floor having what she calls a little snooze - and Mary Ann Singleton is 57. Lord, what would Laura Linney think of that?"

Of course we loved fresh-faced Mary Ann from Cleveland and her rapturous adjustment to the mores of San Francisco in the '70s, but the change is inevitable.  I personally am looking forward to her middle age. 

KATE MORTON:  Kate Morton's The Distant Hours will be out next week.  I loved The Forgotten Garden, a mystery with fairy-tale overtones about three generations of women, which was also partly a homage to The Secret Garden. I am looking forward to this new one.  Publisher's Weekly says:


"A letter posted in 1941 finally reaches its destination in 1992 with powerful repercussions for Edie Burchill, a London book editor, in this enthralling romantic thriller from Australian author Morton (The Forgotten Garden)."

CLEOPATRA:  Reviewers in The Washington Post and The New York Times have praised Stacy Schiff's new biography,  Cleopatra:  A Life , but two other biographies were published earlier this year, Duane W. Roller's  Cleopatra:  A Biography, and Joyce Tyldesley's Cleopatra, Queen of Egypt.  Too many biographies means I won't get around to any of them.  

And that's all for this week, folks!

Thursday, November 04, 2010

The Winds of Heaven

I may have read Monica Dickens' The Winds of Heaven when I was a child.  I had the oddest sense of deja vu as I perused this entertaining novel curled up under the blankets--with the heat off as it is in the '50s by day--enjoying an afternoon's dalliance and escape into the undemanding world of middlebrow novels.   Some of the characters and geographical details seemed inexplicably familiar.  Didn't I know the lonely fat salesman of beds who writes formulaic thrillers, the imaginative but solitary girl who is rejected by her parents, and the friendly, garrulous, carousing middle-aged woman who runs the hotel? 

But I didn't remember the main character, Louise Bickford, so I couldn't have read it, could I?  Maybe I mixed it up with D. E. Stevenson's Mrs. Tim Takes a Job or with one of Monica Dickens's other novels?

If you don't know Monica Dickens's work, it's time to get acquainted.  Dickens, a great-granddaughter of Charles Dickens, is the author of a humorous masterpiece, One Pair of Hands, published in 1937 and never out-of-print. I laughed over this witty autobiography of her jobs as a cook-general, which she embarked on after getting kicked out of drama school. She also wrote several good novels, my favorite of which is The Heart of London.  She founded a branch of The Samaritans in the United States after many years of volunteering for this depression hot-line and drop-in center in England.

It is no surprise that Dickens the Samaritan can write a sensitive novel about social issues without shrieking about it.  No one cares much about older women, and that is Dickens's point in this quick, slight novel about aging without money. Her portrait of Louise Bickford, an unlikely 57-year-old heroine whom no one cares about, is sympathetic and realistic. 

Loitering in a tearoom while waiting for her daughter to pick her up, Louise muses about the sophisticated Londoners and how she appears to them.

"Louise was always much concerned with how people were thinking of her and summing her up; not knowing that a small, middle-aged woman with stubby features and hair no longer brown and not yet grey usually goes unnoticed."
But someone does notice her.  Gordon, the fat man, begins to talk to her in the tearoom, and he gradually over the course of some months becomes her dearest friend.  She is thrilled to meet a writer of mysteries--which her daughter very much disapproves.

Louise is a widow with no money. No one cares much about her since her husband died.  She lives part of the year with each of her three daughters, moving from one daughter's home to the next, spending the winter in a friend's hotel.  Her officious daughter, Miriam, is a busy, traditional lawyer's wife who wants her children to move in the horsey set.  Eva is a self-absorbed actress in London.  Ann lives on a farm and does little except sit on the couch and read novels.  She snaps at her mother constantly. None of them wants responsibility for Louise.

How exactly does one get free of family?  This is not the age when older women get jobs at McDonald's.  Louise's daughters are horrified when she talks about getting a job at a department store.  It is a class thing. They don't want anyone to know they don't want their mother.  Poor Louise's only real freedom from family, though it is not quite that, occurs during the winters at her friend's hotel, and that is certainly a mixed blessing.  She is an inconvenience, hustled away to live in a tiny, cold back room when the hotel fills up or her friend wants to woo new guests, and she does not make friends in the lounge.

Perhaps the most fascinating event is when Louise's son-in-law moves her into a dilapidated caravan on the farm.  Louise is thrilled, but the winter proves exhausting, cold, and bleak.  She does not become independent, as I had thought she might.

The novel is simple but well-written, the scenes in Louise's different homes vividly sketched , and the characters believable. This is not a great novel, but I enjoyed it.  I have to admit I was disappointed with the ending.  Freedom comes to Louise...well, I'll let you guess.

This is not in the class of, say, Barbara Pym's bleak Quartet in Autumn.  Dickens turns it into a traditional women's novel before the end--but, before that, she makes her point.

Wednesday, November 03, 2010

The Year of Reading Classics

Please visit my new blog, The Year of Reading Classics.

In addition to writing Frisbee, I have created this new blog to write a diary of my experiences reading classical literature, i.e., Latin and Greek literature.

I hope you'll enjoy my year of reading classics as much as I will.

Monday, November 01, 2010

Salley Vickers, Connie Willis, and What I'm Reading Now



Salley Vickers, a former psychologist and English professor, is a thoughtful novelist whose work may not be everyone's cup of tea. She writes lovely prose yet parts of her amazing novel, The Other Side of You, are necessarily dull to portray the colorless, emotionally crippled  narrator, David McBride, a psychiatrist, and his sad patient, Elizabeth, a failed suicide.   Eventually the novel metamorphoses into a suspenseful tale of psychological catharsis. Every line, dull or intriguing, is illuminating.  This is one of the most perfect novels I've read this year.

David, the narrator, known as Davey, is a moderately successful psychiatrist-psychoanalyst who does not expect too much.  Moderation is his hallmark and he is only moderately engaged by his wife, friends, and profession. This holding back has been an aspect of him throughout childhood and adulthood and seems to distance him from events. Traumatized at the age of five by the death of his older brother, who stepped out into traffic and was killed by a truck backing up, David has never recovered or quite found out who he is.  He reads Jane Austen--often, except in chick lit books, literary shorthand for someone who needs control--and tries to control the professionally forbidden human urges which lead him to wish to console his patients with pats on the shoulder.

"At that time, Jane Austen was my staple reading, a bulwark, I dare say, against my more disturbing professional encounters.  For me to think of someone as a character in Jane Austen was a compliment.  But, truth to tell, psychiatric patients are not really Jane Austen people.  The Austen world has its quota of narcissists, hypochondriacs, low-grade psychotics, and the marginally depressed.  But none would fetch up in a psychiatric unit."

His patient, Elizabeth Cruikshank, originally characterized as a dull, gray, and shadowy woman, eventually dominates the novel.  Pretty but wan, she has attempted suicide because of a love affair which she failed to pursue.  His comments on an index card describe her perfectly:

"Cruikshank, Elizabeth.
Suicide.
Elegant. Guarded.
Azure blue. Swallow.
A hinterland person."

And her story intrigues him.  She meets Thomas, the love of her life, a man she knew many years ago, en route to Rome on some family business.  She is middle-aged and married, unable to leave her husband, but the two soon become a secret inseparable couple.  Thomas is an art historian, an expert on Caravaggio, and the paintings of Caravaggio play a great part in the novel.  Because David, too, is a fan of Caravaggio, whose torturous paintings mean something to both of them, he is able to help her.

And he breaks the rules of psychiatry, as far as I can tell, by spending many hours with her one evening, even drinking whisky together, because he is so intrigued by her.  They do not have a sexual relationship.  Yet there is a strong bond between them.  Davey is a very kind man, loved by his patients, but this relationship helps to heal not only Elizabeth but to heal him.  And what happens is very surprising.  

I loved this book and want to read her newest, Dancing Backwards, the story of a recently widowed poet on a transatlantic cruise to New York.  I love cruise novels:  it all started with Katherine Anne Porter's Ship of Hope.

Other reading:  I am finishing Connie Willis's All Clear, the sequel to Blackout.  Willis's ostensible time-travel World War II series reads as much like a compelling historical novel as it does science fiction. In 2060 Oxford historians travel back and forth in time; the main characters happen to be doing research on England in World War II. Her characters are unforgettable and their lives riveting, as they become more and more involved with the past: Eileen, a sensitive, responsible young woman, takes care of hoydenish evacuees in Lady Caroline's mansion and is quarantined for so many weeks when the children come down with measles that she somehow can't get back to 2060; Polly, determined to study Londoners' reactions to the Blitz, finds herself incredibly attached to the other people in the bomb shelter and to friends in a department store where she works; Mike is dropped miles away from Dover and ends up by accident at Dunkirk, where he believes he may have saved someone not intended to be saved and changed history; and Mary as an ambulance driver is uncertain whether she has been given the right times and days of bombings (so she won't be hit) or the false ones the government put out to fool the Germans. All are trapped in the 1940s, and All Clear wraps up the story.

What Else I'm Reading: I'm still reading Dr. Zhivago.  I absolutely love this new translation and hope to finish it soon though, as you can see, I have some other books going too.  I also look forward to watching the movie again.  

Friday, October 29, 2010

The Jolly Experience

"The Class,"an award-winning movie
I'm teaching two adult education classes this fall.  
It is not a career. One teaches these because of a passion for the subject, not for monetary rewards.  I don’t go in 9-5, fill out forms, attend union meetings, or deal with test scores.  My subject was cut long ago from most school curricula.   I talked my way into the adult ed program because I thought academic classes had possibilities.  

But I've had to do my bit quietly.  After my first class last fall, my superintendent was up in arms because I was teaching grammar.  I couldn’t figure out a way to teach a language without grammar, so I went ahead and secretly taught it anyway.   
Vocabulary and grammar are the stuff of life to language teachers.  A certain amount of discipline and analysis is necessary to gain proficiency in a language, and, alas, that particular kind of discipline disappears as cuts to the liberal arts eliminate German, Latin, Russian, and other departments.  Without the study of languages our society loses so much.  The ability to see patterns in words and sentences, to analyze structure and style, to understand other cultures, to discover that some languages very sensibly have words for different kinds of snow, and to enrich one's vocabulary with English derivatives.  Grammar can even influence the way people think.  What happens as we become a society without grammar?  A society that thinks "between you and I" is correct (the correct phrase is "between you and me," because the preposition  "between" takes the direct object),  nominates a book called Who Do You Love for the National Book Award ("Whom" is correct, as it is the direct object of the verb "love"), and says "everybody loves their cars" (the singular form of the possessive adjective", his" or "her," is correct because the possessive adjective refers back to "everybody," a singular form)? 
One of my classes is excellent:  students study, translate, write, and tell me up-front that they want to complete chapters, not do parts.  They understand that a certain amount of boredom and memorization is necessary. Of course, many aren't really bored, are fascinated by grammar, enjoy the readings.  And they do their homework.  It’s not that much, honestly.  But as long as they’re taking a class, they might as well learn something, no?  

 This year the other class, alas, is there to socialize.  I am told that I must put up with it.  They are there to have fun. Don't give homework.  It doesn't matter if they do it.  (But I'm still teaching grammar and...oh no, I'd better not go that route.)
For the first time, I really understand the problem with the public schools.  Standards are kept very low.  Students have a right to be there, regardless of behavior. Instead of raising the level by assuming intelligence, one must assume idiocy. One class can go down the drain because of the incivility of a few.  It's all very well to try to teach an academic subject, but teachers can be kept from teaching by the need to make it  "fun" and to please everybody.  One size fits all--or rather, one size fits none.  

One wonders:  do teachers have the right to teach?  

Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Zombie Novels


There is some beautiful writing at the beginning of Carrie Ryan's The Forest of Hands and Teeth:

"My mother used to tell me about the ocean.  She said there was a place where there was nothing but water as far as you could see and that it was always moving, rushing toward you and then away."

As I paged through the first chapter at a bookstore, I was hoping for an all-ages classics, like Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials.   I decided to buy it.

It is, as a matter of fact, a zombie novel.  No one let me in on this.  Laura Miller in "Fresh Hell," an article in The New Yorker, promoted Ryan's novel as a Y.A. dystopian novel.  She expressed much interest in this new dark trend and speculated that youth today were more alienated than others. (Go figure:  we had Catcher in the Rye, they have zombies.)  Suzanne Collins's The Hunger Games made the list, along with Catherine Fisher's Incarceron and James Dasher's The Maze Runner. 

I enjoyed The Hunger Games and Incarceron, fast, fun novels with likable heroes and heroines and a few real questions about ethics and power,  but Carrie Ryan's formulaic novel is not of that class.  It seemed immediately to escape the author's control, turning into a formulaic zombie movie in book form. Think 28 Days Later crossed with Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Richard Matheson's I Am Legend--and I am already under the covers.  Except that Mary, the narrator of The Forest of Hands and Teeth, is a rather anemic heroine, trained to use weapons against zombies but essentially too romantic not to lean on boys and breaking down at crucial moments. Ryan doesn't bother much with the style.

The plot is fast.  Mary, the imaginative narrator, grows up in a village surrounded by a fence.  The zombies, known as the Unconsecrated, infect human beings by their bites.  Mary's  mother becomes a zombie on page 7 while Mary is flirting with Harry by the river. Mary becomes an outcast.  The Sisters, a group of secret-loving nuns who know the true history of the world, shelter her for a while after her mother "turns"--her mother chooses to become a zombie rather than to die.  Although Mary is badly treated by the Sisters, she learns that the nuns have contact with the outside and that a young woman named Gabrielle has come in from the outside with news.  Unfortunately, Gabrielle turns into a super-zombie.

if only Ryan had developed the link between Mary and Gabrielle.  Mary very much identifies with this girl-turned-unconsecrated, but, like so much of this book, it leads nowhere.  The book itself goes nowhere.  On the last page, in the middle of an adventure, the book ends.  We have no choice but to buy Book 2 if we want to know what happened to Mary.

This is like a serialized novel of the 19th century, only I paid $9.99 for it and was expecting an ending.  Not even an attempt to wrap it up.

Sorry, can't support this.

Sunday, October 24, 2010

A New Doctor Zhivago


Today I got out and rode my bike for three hours, was caught in the rain, but returned relaxed after riding in the country. Enjoy the autumn while you can:  the tree in the back yard is bare, the trees in our front yard are still orange, but it's only a matter of time before the cold sets in.  It snowed a year ago Friday.  Soon there will be no more bicycling:  just weekend after weekend of reading Russian novels. 

I didn't get dressed yesterday because I was reading the new translation of Doctor Zhivago. Consider my enthusiasm equal to that generated by Obama's recent visit to a house in my neighborhood.  I couldn't get dressed for that event, either, meaning that I didn't go. But I got psyched at B&N last week over a new translation of Boris Pasternak's masterpiece by Richard Pevear and Larissa Volokhonsky, award-winning translators.  OhmyGod--and I couldn't buy the book, either, because I was already carrying too many packages for my bike pannier.  But a copy managed to appear in the house.  No protests from my husband, either.

The previous English translation of Doctor Zhivago by Manya Harari and Max Hayward came out in 1958.  It was done in haste after the international excitement fueled by Pasternak's winning the Nobel Prize for his Soviet-banned novel, which was first published in Italy in 1957 and banned in Russia until 30 years later.  Pasternak accepted the Nobel by telegram and then had to decline, pressured by the Soviet Union.  His son finally picked up the prize for him in 1989. 
Doctor Zhivago is both a page-turner--I can read this the way others read John Grisham--and a poetic masterpiece.  I am rapt over many passages in this new translation. Here's Yuri's observation of a foul day in autumn.
“The rain poured down most disconsolately, not intensifying and not letting up, despite the fury of the wind, which seemed aggravated by the imperturbability of the water being dashed on the earth. Gusts of wind tore at the shoots of the wild grape vine that twined around one of the terraces.  The wind seemed to want to tear up the whole plant, raised it into the air, shook it about, and threw it down disdainfully like a tattered rug.”
Here is the same passage in the Harari-Hayward translation:
“The rain poured with a dreary steadiness, neither hurrying nor slowing down for all the fury of the wind, which seemed enraged by the indifference of the water and shook the creeper on one of the houses as if meaning to tear it up by the room, swinging it up into the air, and dropping it in disgust like a torn rag.”
Actually I like both translations. The new one is  more elegant, the old one more concise.  Those who feel Pasternak just won the Nobel for political reasons--my husband tells me that’s the general view--may be very interested in this new, fuller version of Doctor Zhivago.
More later. 

Saturday, October 23, 2010

Siberia, Lucky to Be Here, and P.S.

Don't get up.  I'm writing this in lounge position.  See all those pillows?  I'm pretending I'm Oblomov.   Every time my husband sees me, he says, "You're still in your pajamas."  Yup.  There are days like this.  You read and sip tea and finally jump into your shoes just to go downstairs and do the laundry. Then you recline again. I was supposed to make squash soup, but in the end I didn't feel up to it. 
I have four books going, three of which are classics, and I'll report on them later.  One is a real classic (NOT Madame Bovary; I've already given up on that, and, alas, find Lydia Davis's translation even clumsier than Alan Russell's); a 1980s novel by a Big Name; and one extremely good contemporary novel by a little-known English writer.  The fourth, alas, I can't recommend:  a Y.A. paranormal romance I was suckered into buying after it somehow got the lead review on the L.A. Times Books Webpage.  

Because of my susceptibility to well-reviewed bad books, I've begun a moratorium on book-buying.  I'm lighting a candle and flashing the peace sign to publishers in hopes that they'll "release" better books next year.
But here are some books, recommended by various reivewers, that I do want to read.  Perhaps they're good.  

1. Travels in Siberia by Ian Frazier. We love Sandy Frazier's books. He's intelligent, funny, and does good research.  Of course, he doesn't know us, but we call him "Sandy" because I interviewed him once and that seemed to be his name.  I obtained his autograph on a copy of Family, a memoir of growing up in Hudson, Ohio, combined elegantly with his family history, which I highly recommend.
According to the San Francisco Chronicle,  "Frazier was in his early 40s when he became 'infected' with a love for Russia. (He is now 59.) After meeting the Russian conceptual artists Vitaly Komar and Alex Melamid, Frazier became friends with Melamid and his wife, Katya. They invited him to accompany them on a 1993 trip to Moscow - their first trip home after a 15-year exile - and Frazier found Moscow to be merely a gateway drug to Siberia, where he would return time and again over subsequent years, like a hopeless years, like a hopeless addict. "At what point can you say you have traveled in Siberia enough?" he writes.

2.  Keith Richards's Life.  I didn't know who Keith Richards was till I heard that a friend of a friend had had an affair with him. I love the Rolling Stones, never followed any rock stars' lives, and didn't know any of their names (except Mick). I am, however, interested in the survival thing after the deaths of so many:  Jim Morrison, Janis Joplin, Keith Moon, Kurt Cobain, and surely one of the Rolling Stones. In the Martin Scorsese film about the Rolling Stones, Richards said he felt lucky to be here.  (And don't I know what he means, in a different way?)

The New York Times  says: "He’s been through quite a lot of phases. And they’re all on the page in “Life”: the Boy Scout (really); the tyro rocker; the lovestruck kid (mad for Ronnie Spector, unbeknownst to Phil Spector); the astonished new star; the heroin-addicted older one; the jaded veteran of countless world tours; and the longtime sparring partner of Mick Jagger....All of this is recounted with straight-up candor, and some of it is easily sensationalized. But the book’s single biggest stunner is a hand-written note on its jacket flap: 'Believe it or not, I haven’t forgotten any of it.'”  I'm quite a bit kinder to memoirs than I am to paranormal romances, so I might like it.  

3.  P.S.  Iowa City, UNESCO City of Literature, celebrates Tolstoy, Chekhov, and the UI Russian program this month.  You can attend a public reading of Anna Karenina by the fountain downtown Oct. 27-30, Wed. and Th. 9 a.m. to 10 p.m., and Friday and Saturday 9 a.m.-6 p.m.  There are also many, many other events, like a staged reading of Chekhov's The Cherry Orchard and an exhibit of Mauricio Lasansky's "Tolstoy."  I'm cyber-inviting A Work in Progress (who inspired me to reread AK last spring) and Dovegreyreader might as well come, too, since she's reading War and Peace.  I don't live in Iowa city, but it's a lovely town.

Book Giveaway

"Any books to give away?"  That's my husband speaking. He needs stamps, and if there's one sure-fire way to get them, it's to do our cyber-trading of books for stamps.
I have two books to give away.
1.  Saki's The Unbearable Bassington.  I enjoyed this novel, reviewed here, but it it's included in my Complete Saki.  So my lovely Capuchin copy is available. 
2.  Connie Willis's Doomsday Book, winner of the Hugo and Nebula Awards.  This very popular science fiction book is about time travel to the Middle Ages and a faulty time machine.  Most loved it; honestly, I only read half.  

If you'd like one of these, leave your first name and the title of the book in a comment.  I'll do the drawing on Monday, but if you're the only one then the book is yours.  The book is free, but you'll reimburse me for the postage.  

Bonam fortunam!